In our last two posts on this series we discussed how SWP from ICICI Prudential Balanced Fund and Reliance Regular Savings Fund Balanced option were proved to be good options if one was looking for regular returns by using the SWP method. Today we will analyze how the same worked for Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan.
As you know already Balanced Mutual Funds invests 65 – 75 % of the portfolio in equities and rest in debt or money market instruments and also that the balanced funds are subject to equity taxation as these are hybrid equity oriented mutual funds. Long term capital gains, for investment period of more than 1 year and the dividends received from balanced funds - both are tax free. Short term capital gains applicable for investments of less than 1 year are taxed at 15%.
Readers interested to know more about Balanced Funds are suggested to read the following articles on our website –
Can mutual fund balanced fund be your best bet
Investing in balanced funds versus a portfolio of equity and debt funds
Why balanced funds may be the best investments for new mutual fund investors
What is Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) in Mutual Funds
Systematic Withdrawal Plan or SWP, as popularly known, is a service offered by Mutual Funds which provides investors withdrawal of a specific amount of payout at a pre determined time frequency, like weekly, fortnightly, monthly, quarterly, half-yearly or annually.
Unfortunately, this is a much underestimated investment strategy in India. If understood properly, this could become the most effective and tax efficient way to earn regular returns from Mutual funds. Through a series of our articles on SWP, we will try educate the investors about SWP, how it works and the tax benefits etc. by showing some examples of top performing Balanced Funds.
How SWP worked in case of Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan
If you had invested
र 10 Lacs in Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan on January 1, 2001 and withdrawn र 8,000 per month from January 2, 2002, then the current value of your investment would have been र 61.06 Lakhs even after withdrawing र 14.00 Lakhs! We presumed that the monthly SWP withdrawal of र 8,000 was started after one year (starting date January 2, 2002) from the date of investment (January 1, 2001) and thereafter on the 2nd day of every month so that each and every SWP amount in the hands of the investor is tax free.
Please look at the image below to understand how we have selected the different options in the research tool to get this result. You can also explore this SWP Research tool to explore SWP return of any fund you like.
Source: Advisorkhoj SWP Calculator (Data as on 18/7/2016)
SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan) results
From the above chart you can see that the investor would have withdrawn a total of
र 14.00 Lakhs through 175 equal monthly SWP instalments of र 8,000 each, thus, he would have got a tax free return of 9.6% every year. Even after withdrawing a tax free amount of र 14.00 Lakhs, the current value of his investment would stand at र 61.06 Lakhs! The SWP returns were annualised (IRR) 17.07%.
You may Download the cash flow in excel and check
Can SWP take care of Inflation?
Inflation is a very vital point when you are planning your investments. In fact, two things are very important in any investment planning – Post tax return and inflation adjusted return - therefore, in this study, we will also analyse what happens when we increase the SWP amount by 5% every year (presuming average inflation rate of 5%).
Source: Advisorkhoj SWP Calculator with Annual increase (Data as on 18/7/2016)
From the above image, you can see that the investor would have withdrawn a total of
र 18.76 Lakhs through 175 increasing SWP instalments, starting from Rs. 8,000 per month in the first year and ending with र 13,600 per month in the last year. Therefore, he would have got a tax free return of 9.6% in the first year which gradually increased every year and in the last year it was 16.32%. Even after withdrawing a tax free amount of र 18.76 Lacs, the current value of his investment would be र 50.19 Lakhs! The fund gave an annualised (IRR) 17.13% return. Please check the details here
Please download the cash flow in excel and check how it worked?
Let us now see how the SWP amount increased over a period of time, the increasing withdrawal % on the lumpsum amount and how the value of net investments changed annually post these systematic withdrawals.
You will notice from the above image, how we have increased the SWP amount annually by 5% on the initial investment. You will also notice that during this entire period, the net investment value dropped to lesser than the initial lumpsum investment amount i.e.
र 10.00 Lacs, only during the initial period of 20 months (January 2002 to August 2003). You must have also noticed that barring these 20 month, the remaining period the net investment value never gone down to less than the initial investment of र 10.00 Lacs even though we increased the SWP amount by 5% annually. It proves that if you remain invested over long period in balanced funds then the trailing returns should be positive.
Now let us see the annual returns of Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan against VR hybrid Equity Oriented index
You will notice that during the last 15 years, the fund has beaten the VR-Hybrid Equity Index in most of the years excepting 2001 and 2008 only when the markets passed through volatile times.
About Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund
Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund is a hybrid equity oriented fund, popularly known as balanced funds. Launched in February 1995, it is another popular fund in the Balanced Fund category from one of India’s top AMCs, Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund, having AUM of
र 3,140 Crores (As on June 30, 2016). It is one of the best performing Balanced Funds in the industry with quite a long term track record of more than 20 years! Renowned fund manager Mahesh Patil manages this fund along Pranay Sinha.
The top 5 stocks that the fund is invested in, are – HDFC Bank. Infosys, Maruti Suzuki and Tata Motors and ICICI Bank. The 3 top sectors are Energy, Financial and Automobile.
We reviewed this fund sometime back but which is still relevant - 19 years of superb performance by Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund
Lumpsum returns of Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan
So far we discussed the SWP returns of Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth plan and found how amazing the results were. Let us now examine the lumpsum returns of this fund. Had you invested
र 10 Lacs in this fund on January 01, 2001 then the current fund value would have been a decent र 1.21 Crores, a superb CAGR return of 17.41%. For this same period, if this amount was invested in fixed deposit, Gold and silver, then you would have got only र 28.39 Lakhs, र 64.61 Lakhs and र 46.65 Lakhs respectively.
Please check here – Comparison of fund return with FD, Gold and Silver
SIP Returns of Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan
The SIP returns of Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan have also been very good! If you had started a monthly SIP of
र 5,000 on January 01, 2001, then you would have accumulated a corpus of र 45.83 Lakhs, based on NAV of July 20, 2016 whereas you had invested only र 9.35 Lakhs through 187 instalments of र 5,000 each. During this period the fund has given a excellent XIRR return of 18.37% which is one of the best amongst the peer group of schemes. Check out SIP Return Calculator
If you had done a SIP of same amount for the same period in CNX Nifty then the current value would have been only
र 29.97 Lakhs with a return of 13.70% only.
Source: Advisorkhoj SIP Calculator
In fact, in one of our studies, we found that in the long run the top balanced fund SIP returns were as good as large cap equity funds. To know more, kindly read this How SIPs in top balanced funds have created as much wealth as large cap funds
Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund – Growth Plan has given excellent SWP returns in last 15 years and so and may be a good choice for investors looking for regular income from their lumpsum investments in balanced funds by taking only moderate risk. However, investors should note that past performance of mutual funds are no guarantees for future returns. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risk and therefore investors must consult their financial advisors and check if investment in Birla Sun Life Balanced 95 Fund is suited for their investment needs based on their risk profile.
Readers interested in knowing more about SWP, may read the following contents –
Mutual Funds are ideal investment option for retirement planning
Mutual Fund systematic withdrawal plans are smart option for income needs
Mutual Fund Investments are subject to market risk, read all scheme related documents carefully.